PDA

View Full Version : Prose: first breath


charcoal
01-31-2008, 7:39 AM
Hi guys, I'm thinking of submitting this to an anthology, and I'd really appreciate any comments/criticism since I still have a week or two to redraft.

First Breath

The church bells wake me. I open my eyes and realise that I'm alone beneath the lilac sky. Alone but for the river and the leaves it guides atop it.

And now it is dawn. Or dusk. Or simply one of those curious afternoons where the clouds encompass the earth and nothing is clear. But the water is clear, and cold, so I take off my shoes. I unbutton my dress, shivering, and slip into the river.

The current runs fast and deep, and I'm overwhelmed by the rush and the cold and my face is slapped by the wet ochre-and-red slivers that mark the end of the autumnal abscission for the riverside trees.

My teeth clatter but still cannot drown the sound of my heartbeat, thundering in my chest and my ears.

And the water gets deeper here by the bridge and the current runs deeper still and further from the banks and I'm helpless to resist the cold hands that lure me under. I breathe and I breathe water as cold and crystalline and cruel as the realisation that

this isn’t what I want!

PyroOwned
01-31-2008, 7:52 AM
Very Anthology-like. I'm doing Anthology in school, and that would really fit in. Go for it! :thup:

Jiggz
01-31-2008, 7:57 AM
It must be difficult to assess what makes a good prose, no? What are the criterion to consider?

To my uneducated eyes, it seems beautifully written. I felt cold reading it. Maybe my air-con is on too high again.

Pyro
01-31-2008, 10:39 AM
It is indeed greatly written. If you try you can feel everything that happens to the character. I think I would leave it just the way it is.

Godly
02-01-2008, 1:26 PM
I don't really know anything about anthology, but I do know that that was a pretty good little bit of prose you just wrote. The only thing I maybe don't like about it is the last line. Other then that, it's fantastic.

jewishjosh
02-01-2008, 8:01 PM
I love your stream of consciousness style of writing. The use of the word 'curious' jumped out at me (in a good way). The blend of your writing style and vocabulary is beautiful. Your descriptions are good.

I think it's great. Don't change it unless you're having second thoughts about a specific part. Rely on your gut more than our advice.